112 North Main Street,
North Liberty IN 46554
574-656-3321
The Bakery
Ask The Decorator
PIE
Pies 9" Deep Dish
Chocolate Cream Silk
Peanut Butter Cream
Pecan Cream
Unbaked 9" pie shell
Apple or Blueberry Strudel
Cherry, Pumpkin, Sugar Cream
Peach, Lemon Meringue
Strawberry Rhubarb
$11.25
$11.25
$14.95
$7.00
$18.95
$19.95
$21.95
$21.95
No Gluten Pies 9" Deep Dish
Unbaked 9" pie shell
with solid top
Apple Fruit
Blueberry Fruit
Peach Fruit
Cherry
(Options: Regular, Crumble, w/ Lattice Top)
Sugar Cream, Butterscotch
Strawberry Rhubarb
Lemon Meringue
Pecan
Raisin
Banana Cream, Coconut Cream,
$4.00
$5.00
$12.59
$12.95
$15.29
$16.95 - $17.95
$14.79
$15.29
$16.95
$26.95
$15.95
$11.25
Other Flavors By Request
To Place A Pie Order
CLICK HERE
Call or Contact Us!
Let us know your contact information, how many pies you need, what date and time for pick up and the flavors you want!
Over The Top Bakery Cafe © 2026 All Rights Reserved. Moon Storm Creative